BUSINESS

A Swift fall in Esteem for Maruti Suzuki

Automobile, Viewed [ 30 ] , Rating :
     
Star Live 24, Star Live 24
Sunday, March 02, 2014
Published On: 22:19:12 PM
Comments

It has been a downhill ride in the last one month for car industry leader and stock market darling Maruti Suzuki which is embroiled in a controversy of its own making. Investors, analysts and the stock market are up in arms over the proposal by Suzuki Motor Corporation (SMC), which owns 56 per cent of Maruti Suzuki, to set up a new plant in Gujarat as a wholly-owned subsidiary. They sent Maruti’s stock plunging by 8.12 per cent on January 28, the day the decision was announced. On Friday, the company sent a clarification to the stock exchanges but it raises more questions than it answers. Not surprising then that the market voted with its feet again sending Maruti’s shares tumbling down by 4.53 per cent.

If the original announcement was patronising to Maruti’s shareholders and flawed in its financial logic, the clarification put out on Friday raises concerns over transfer pricing strategies. SMC’s wholly-owned Gujarat subsidiary will operate on the basis that it will neither make a loss nor a cash surplus. If you thought this means that the subsidiary will supply to Maruti at cost, you are wrong.

Cars manufactured on contract basis for Maruti by the Gujarat subsidiary of SMC would be priced in a manner that will generate a 'surplus' to fund the subsidiary’s capital expenditure, says the clarification. Of course, the company has also very kindly clarified that such price would be lower than what Maruti charges its dealers so that it can build in its margin. But how much lower? And why should the capital expenditure of the SMC subsidiary be funded by Maruti when it has no stake? Investors are agitated over the basic question of why SMC should branch out on its own when Maruti has the financial resources and management bandwidth to implement the project as its third plant. The land for the Gujarat plant has already been paid for by Maruti and it is obvious to assume that its managers, contractors and vendors will play a key role in implementing the project for SMC.

The existence of a fully-owned subsidiary of SMC and a partially-owned one, both dealing in the same business, raises obvious questions of conflict of interests. Will SMC’s new products and technology be channelled through Maruti or the new wholly-owned subsidiary? SMC has defended its decision saying that Maruti will benefit from interest earnings on its huge cash resources of over Rs.7,000 crore by not investing in the project. But where is the money now invested? In unquoted units. And what did it earn? All of Rs. 313.40 crore as interest in 2012-13, which is a piffling 4.5 per cent rate.

In comparison, Maruti’s return on capital employed, which is a rough estimate of what the cash might earn if invested in a project, was a little over 15 per cent in the same year. How does SMC then say that Maruti will benefit by not investing? If that was bad logic, this takes the cake: Maruti can apparently 'avoid all risk inherent in any investment' by not investing in the new plant, according to the statement. If it is not the karma of a corporate manufacturing enterprise to invest in growth, what is?

The bottomline is this: SMC’s strategy is not favourable to Maruti and it is shocking that the Japanese multinational can do this to its Indian subsidiary which earns more than what the parent earns in Japan. The strategy is hostile to minority shareholders, and institutional investors, who are already miffed, should carry their protests to the logical conclusion. SMC is trying to have the cake and eat it too; it should not be allowed to get away with it.

[email protected] Uttarakhand.co.in

Other Videos


Jeev nominated for Asian Tour’s ‘Player of the Decade’ award

Jeev nominated for Asian Tour’s ‘Player of the Decade’ award

Pakistan and India can play bilateral series after IPL: PCB chief

Pakistan and India can play bilateral series after IPL: PCB chief

Toyota India lifts lockout, workers refuse to budge

Toyota India lifts lockout, workers refuse to budge

A Gandhi shows the way in US: Stop peddling family name

A Gandhi shows the way in US: Stop peddling family name

Russian troops seize Ukraine marine base in Crimea: Officials

Russian troops seize Ukraine marine base in Crimea: Officials

US Navy black box locator joins search for missing Malaysian plane

US Navy black box locator joins search for missing Malaysian plane

Turkish jet downs Syrian warplane near border

Turkish jet downs Syrian warplane near border

French radar data expands search for MH370 but rain may hamper hunt

French radar data expands search for MH370 but rain may hamper hunt




 Comment Note: By posting your comments in our website means you agree to the terms and conditions of www.StarLive24.tv
More From This Section
  • Toyota India Lifts Lockout, Workers Refu..
  • Emerging Markets Grow Fast When They Tur..
  • COAI Seeks Reconfiguration Of Blocks In ..
  • Bitcoin Gang Nears 200-Member Mark; Outn..
  • Legal Opinion Sought On Inclusion Of RIL..
  • Airasia India Gets First Aircraft
  • SBI To Sell Rs.3,000 Cr Bad Loans This F..
  • Jayalalithaa's Intervention Sought In No..
  • Jayalalitha's Intervention Sought In Nok..
  • SBI To Sell Bad Loans Of Rs 3,000 Cr Thi..
  • Mahila Bank To Open 55-60 New Branches I..
  • Ready To Resume Work But Won’T Sign Unde..
  • First Aircraft Of Airasia India Lands In..
  • Loop Telecom Ltd Plea For Settlement: Co..
  • OVL Asked To Re-Evaluate Withdrawal From..


Related Search
  • Automobile
  • Economy
  • Interview
  • Markets


> >

1/4

Most Viewed

Daimler To Set Up Bus Unit Near Chennai